Headline Story

Rent Control Gains Traction Amid Housing Crisis in Bay Area

Like a monster that’s been hiding in the basement for decades, rent control is rearing its head in the Bay Area. Whether it is an ugly countenance or a smiling face is a matter of perspective.
 
While the Bay Area has struggled with housing shortages and rising rents for the past decade or so, it has become evident that no amount of development will, in the near term, bring rents back down to manageable levels for residents earning median incomes and below. As tech jobs have made Bay Area residents more wealthy, and attracted newcomers flush with cash, landlords in unregulated cities have tried to cash in by raising rents and even evicting incumbent tenants. 

Therefore, over the past year, cities have again turned to what is, in many ways, the tool of last resort to preserve affordable housing.
 
“A year ago we had the wild west,” said Eric Strimling, spokesperson for the Alameda Renters Coalition, of Alameda’s rental market. “There were pretty much no regulation at all. Evict at will, raise rents at will.”
 

»   Please Login or Subscribe to view this article.

Untitled

The City of Los Angeles has chosen a developer for a wholesale produce market and additional manufacturing space on a site where a controversial state prison was once proposed. The city chose Richard Meruelo to develop the 20-acre parcel near Washington Boulevard and Santa Fe Avenue near L.A.’s Eastside neighborhood.

In the mid-1980s, activists fought a proposal from Gov. George Deukmejian to build a high-rise prison on the site. Residents of the heavily Latino district said the state was d...

NEPA: Army Corps Need Not Analyze All of Playa Vista, Ninth Circuit Rules

In a major victory for developers of Playa Vista, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has reinstated an Army Corps of Engineers permit to fill 16 acres of wetlands. The unanimous three-judge appellate panel overturned a district court ruling that the Corps did not adequately consider environmental impacts of the overall project.

The Ninth Circuit held that the Corps did not need to complete an environmental impact statement and that the Corps was correct to review only the wetlands portion o...

California Supreme Court: First Dibs On Water Rights Carries The Day; Thirsty Cities Remain Dry

In an important water rights ruling, the state Supreme Court has held that farmers’ long-standing water rights superceded water claims by downstream cities. The unanimous court ruled in favor of seven alfalfa and dairy farmers in the Mojave Valley that had refused to join a pact that allocated water to more than 200 farmers, cities and other entities without regard to historical water rights. "This preserves the farmers’ position at basically the top of the water chain," Robert Dougherty, t...

Legislature Strengthens LAFCOs, But Fiscal Reform Remains Elusive

The state Legislature completed its two-year session with a flourish during the last week of August but appeared to leave Sacramento without adopting major land-use policy changes. Assembly Speaker Robert Hertzberg’s overhaul of the Cortese-Knox Local Government Reorganization Act was among the year’s highlights, although he watered down the measure from early drafts. The broad-based Jobs-Center Housing Coalition, which has focused on the Bay Area housing crunch, saw three of its nine bills approved.

California Supreme Court: Decision Against Santa Monica Rent Control Law is Decertified

The State Supreme Court decertified a Second District Court of Appeal opinion that overturned portions of Santa Monica’s rent control law.

The appellate court ruled that Santa Monica could not modify conditions established by state law under which landlords can increase rents for voluntarily vacated units. The court also held that the city cannot demand more information than state law requires when registering rent-controlled units. (See CP&DR Legal Digest, June 2000.)

In reviewing the Cos...

Litigation Likely Regarding New Federal Fish Regulations

A day before his agency issued sweeping regulations to protect threatened salmon and steelhead in California, Oregon, Idaho and Washington, Will Stelle was matter-of-fact about the likely reaction: litigation.

As northwest regional administrator for the National Marine Fisheries Service, he’s been in the hot seat for years as the region has struggled to reverse the devastation visited upon native fish species by dams, farming, urban development, road construction, logging, water diversions, and co...

Untitled

The City of Hawaiian Gardens illegally spent $4 million in redevelopment funds to help an influential businessman open a card club, according to a Joint Legislative Audit Committee report issued in July. The scathing report accuses the city and businessman Irving Moskovitz of violating a 1996 law that prohibits the use of redevelopment funds for gambling establishments. Moskovitz is the largest landowner in the southern Los Angeles County city, and donations from his charitable foundations repo...

The Missing Link? Cities Want Business to Fund Affordable Housing

Linkage fees are back. But will they do any good — or any harm?

A "linkage fee" is a fee imposed on one kind of development to help fund a different kind of development that otherwise might not get built. Most commonly, this means slapping a fee on commercial development (which presumably brings more jobs to a community) in order to fund affordable housing development (which presumably will house the workers who take the jobs).

Linkage was all the rage back in the late ’80s — when office developmen...

Path to Nice Roads Bypasses California

You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it drink. Likewise, you can lead California’s road builders to ISTEA/TEA-21Transportation Enhancements, but you apparently can’t make them take advantage of the matching funds. That’s a shame because this resistance ensures that the state has poorly landscaped roads, fewer bridge and railroad depot renovations, and minimal interpretive centers for historic and scenic area.

The Transportation Enhancement (TE) program is a cornerstone o...

Path to Nice Roads Bypasses California

You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it drink. Likewise, you can lead California’s road builders to ISTEA/TEA-21Transportation Enhancements, but you apparently can’t make them take advantage of the matching funds. That’s a shame because this resistance ensures that the state has poorly landscaped roads, fewer bridge and railroad depot renovations, and minimal interpretive centers for historic and scenic area.

The Transportation Enhancement (TE) program is a cornerstone o...

Local Adult Business Zoning Gets 3 Hearings in Ninth Circuit

In three adult business cases decided in late June, the Ninth District Court of Appeals upheld one city’s zoning ordinance, struck down another city’s code and sent a third city’s regulatory system back to district court for further proceedings.

The court upheld the City of Taft’s ordinance that restricts adult businesses to a select few parcels in town, but it struck down a similar ordinance in Simi Valley as unconstitutional because that city’s process essentially permitted third parties to block ad...

Councilman Defends Right to decide Own Appeal: Court Rules Applicant can Still receive a Fair Hearing

A city councilmember can appeal a planning commission decision and then cast a vote on the appeal, the Second District Court of Appeal has ruled. The court decided that the owner of a pool hall in Torrance who sought a permit to sell alcohol could get a fair hearing in such circumstances.

The unanimous three-judge panel made clear that the case was dissimilar to a 1994 case in which the Second District ruled that it was a conflict of interest for the Thousand Oaks City Council to appeal a ...

Councilman Defends Right to decide Own Appeal: Court Rules Applicant can Still receive a Fair Hearing

A city councilmember can appeal a planning commission decision and then cast a vote on the appeal, the Second District Court of Appeal has ruled. The court decided that the owner of a pool hall in Torrance who sought a permit to sell alcohol could get a fair hearing in such circumstances.

The unanimous three-judge panel made clear that the case was dissimilar to a 1994 case in which the Second District ruled that it was a conflict of interest for the Thousand Oaks City Council to appeal a ...

Subdivison Map Act: Ruling Against ‘Paper Subdivisions’ Will Not Stand as Precedent

A recent appellate court opinion that cast doubt on the legal status of thousands of lots in 19th century subdivisions has been decertified.

The California Supreme Court ordered the depublication of the Second District Court of Appeals’ decision in Circle K Ranch Corp. v. Board of Supervisors of the County of Santa Barbara, B124996 (see CP&DR Legal Digest, May 2000). However, the state’s high court did not accept the case for review.

The Second District ruled that separate parcels do not exist today...

Variances: Government Regulations Can Be Grounds for Variance, Court Rules

Santa Cruz County’s granting of six variances for a new house on the beach has been upheld by the Sixth District Court of Appeal. The unanimous three-judge panel ruled that the county could consider federal and county regulations as "special circumstances" in approving variance requests.

The controversy was centered on some of Santa Cruz County’s most desirable real estate, namely, Beach Drive, next to Rio Del Mar Beach, in Aptos. In 1996, Jim and Judi Craik purchased a house at 415 Beach D...

Guideline Authors Allege Misreading; State supreme Court to Decide

The two principal authors of the 1998 revisions to the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines say a recent appellate court decision misinterpreted the Guidelines. The case, Friends of Sierra Madre v. City of Sierra Madre, (1999) 76 Cal.App.4th 1061, has since been accepted for review by the state Supreme Court.

Last December, the Second District Court of Appeal overturned an election in which voters approved a city-sponsored ballot measure to remove 29 properties from the city’s Register of H...