top of page

CEQA Barely Survives A Mock Execution At Cal APA – But "It May Need Some Botox"

Oct 12
3 min read

The question posed in one panel at the California Chapter, American Planning Association, conference last week was whether the California Environmental Quality Act should live or die. Everybody had a paddle – not to swat each other, but to vote yes or no. And despite the fact that most of the people in the room make their living as CEQA practitioners, the vote was surprisingly close.


The format was a bit contrived, as two debating teams – each made up of two CEQA practitioners – took opposite sides. One side argued that “CEQA is Dead,” while the other argued “Long Live CEQA”. But the outcome was illuminating – and led to some interesting observations about how CEQA might be changed.


Speaking for the “Killing CEQA” side, Darcy Kremin of ESA compared CEQA to a fishing boat that has had so many holes poked in it that it’s sinking. “It’s outgrown its usefulness,” she said, adding: “We can’t solve problems project by project. We need to look bigger — regionally.”


Her argument was backed up by Bob Stark of Michael Baker International, who invoked the “Bob’s Mom Test,” saying that he tells his staff that his mother must be able to understand CEQA documents and “that’s not working right now.”


“We’re writing the documents for the attorneys, because we all know where this is going to end up,” he said.


The Long Live CEQA team said the problem isn’t CEQA. Rather, said John Bellas of Michael Baker International (yes, MBI argued both sides) it’s the special interests in Sacramento – unions, lobbyists, wealthy communities – that are driving CEQA abuse.


Rather than criticizing all the holes punched in the leaky boat, Bellas said that one-off CEQA breaks given to major projects such as Midway Rising in San Diego (see CP&DR coverage here) may not be a bad thing. “There may be wisdom in the Legislature shepherding big, needed projects that will draw opposition anyway,” he said.


His teammate Florentina Craciun of AECOM reiterated that CEQA’s basic role is to ensure “an informed decision and a community that understands the basis for it, even when people disagree with the outcome.” Maybe her strongest argument is the idea that CEQA has changed the mindset of applicants, who come to the table with mitigations already in mind. She noted that a recent survey by the Association of Environmental Professionals found that 77% of projects are exempt from CEQA.


After a lot of back-and-forth among the debaters and Q&A, the audience – easily 200 people – voted with the paddles. Moderator Suzanne Varco of Varco & Rosenbaum appeared surprised that the vote was close. Even though she did not have a rigorous method for counting the votes, she declared that CEQA had won – barely.


Once the vote was over, the two teams largely converged around a few possible botox-style improvemens to CEQA. These included the following:

 

-  Stop fighting over initial studies, mitigated negative decs, etc. Just call everything an environmental impact report – and make it simple.

-  Simplify Appendix G – the list of potential environmental impacts – by tying “significance” not to the judgment of the person filling out the form but to specific standards already in state law.

-  Related: codify standard mitigations, thus making Appendix G less important.

-  Revise alternatives so that they are required only when there are significant unmitigated impacts, and …

-  Ban “percentage reduction” alternatives to ensure that every alternative is actually a realistic, buildable project.

-  And this one got huge applause: The loser in a CEQA lawsuit should always pay the attorneys fees.

Varco noted that many of these reforms are included in Proposition 45, the CEQA reform measure sponsored by the California Chamber of Commerce that’s on the November ballot. But Prop. 45 didn’t get as big a round of applause as making the losers pay attorneys fees.  

The Panelists

 

Moderator: Suzanne Varco, Varco & Rosenbaum Environmental Law Group, svarco@envirolawyer.com

 

“CEQA Is Dead”

Darcy Kremin, ESA, dkremin@esassoc.com

Bob Stark, Michael Baker International, bstark@mbakerintl.com

 

“Long Live CEQA”

Florentina Craciun, AECOM, florentina.craciun@aecom.com

John Bellas, Michael Baker International, jbellas@mbakerintl.com

bottom of page