Q&A Podcast: L.A. Planner-Councilmember Nithya Raman
Updated: 3 days ago
Elected to the Los Angeles City Council in November, Nithya Raman ran on an explicitly urbanist platform. Her slogan: "Nithya for the city." Raman arrived at public service via urban planning. She earned her master's in urban planning from MIT and spend several years working her in native India, advocating for impoverished populations in Delhi and Chennai.

Raman's council district, District 4, spans both sides of the Hollywood Hills, including wealthy, homeowner-dominated neighborhoods like Larchmont Village and Sherman Oaks as well as denser, lower-income neighborhoods like Van Nuys and Hollywood. Raman's city council platform includes several planks related to progressive land use and attention to disadvantaged populations, including rent forgiveness, subsidized housing, and vastly increased services and housing options for unhoused people. Raman is the second urban planner to serve on the Los Angeles City Council and the first to serve since Ed Reyes was termed out in 2013.
CP&DR's Josh Stephens spoke with Raman on February 18, 2021.
Audio available on platforms including Spotify and Google Podcasts, here. This is Josh Stephens with the California Planning & Development Report, and I'm here with newly elected and installed Los Angeles City Councilwoman Nithya Raman, who is a planner by training, and we'll find out more about that in this podcast. Councilmember Raman, welcome to the podcast.
Thank you so much for having me, and I appreciate you saying my name very, very accurately.
Oh, good, I'm glad. And, full disclosure, I'm not one of your direct constituents, but I'm here in CD 11, so I am generally under the sway of the LA City Council. You've only been on council for a few weeks now, but I'd love to ask you first: what have you learned about land use from your perspective as an elected official that you hadn't known or hadn't thought about as a trained planner?
It's been an interesting time in office. This is a time of heated discussions around planning and land use across the state, as you very well know, and obviously a lot of those discussions have filtered up to the office and into our conversations with constituents and constituent groups.
One of the things that has surprised me is how much engagement there is between projects happening in the district and the city council office, even in cases where the council office has less discretion to be involved. There's still significant engagement, and there are still significant opportunities for the council office to talk to all kinds of players in the district about issues really related to land use. I always knew that part of the landscape of land use and planning in the city of Los Angeles is a huge amount of interaction between council offices and what happens in their districts. But I think it's more porous and more intense than I had realized as an outsider.
For our listeners around the state, why don't you describe your district briefly and the land use concerns you're seeing among your constituents?
The district is very oddly shaped and encompasses a range of housing types and neighborhoods. I live in Silver Lake, which is one end of the district. It goes from Los Feliz and Silver Lake, which are a mix of single-family homes and apartments, into Hollywood, which is primarily multiunit buildings, and Koreatown, which is the same. Then there's the Mid-City area, Hancock Park, and Mid-Wilshire around LACMA. There are a significant number of large investments being planned there that are going to change how land use happens and how people move through that space, like the Purple Line.
Then there are all of the Hollywood Hills, which are their own unique geography: narrow streets, high fire risk, and a topography that makes it challenging to build, plus huge amounts of open space that is still in a pristine natural environment, which people are fighting to protect. And it extends into the Valley, which has its own set of transportation challenges and other neighborhood issues.
All of these neighborhoods have really different concerns when they reach out to the office. They range from density and how much building is permitted in their neighborhoods, to what I would still consider land-use-related issues, like access to affordable housing and people struggling with rent and with their landlords. In a city where rental units are scarce, it has been challenging in the past for renters to have much leverage. So there's a lot going on in the district, and it's so varied and so vast that it encompasses the full gamut of issues facing the city of Los Angeles as a whole.
I actually forgot to mention that Griffith Park is entirely within the district. There, the questions are about preserving nature and maintaining that environment while also allowing a park-poor city to have access to one of its most incredible resources. It's astounding how many issues there are that are really related to planning.
Is that geographic diversity a bonanza for someone with a planning perspective, or do you sometimes wish your district were more homogenous so you could identify common issues throughout it?
It certainly poses a challenge. What I have to figure out as a representative, and what we have to figure out as an office and a team, is what skills we need to serve the very diverse needs of our residents. Council offices usually have two planners. But in our office, because of the larger projects and investments happening, like the LACMA redesign and construction, the Purple Line coming in, the planned Valley transit investments through Metro, and the challenges residents face because of the Burbank and Van Nuys airports in the Valley, there are so many issues related in a broad way to transit and transportation.
Even though I'm not on the transportation committee in council, one of the things we've been thinking about is that we need someone on the team with focused experience in transportation and problem solving, especially at the interface between access and bigger projects, and how those shape the way people move around public spaces in the city.
Now that you're on council, how much do you see yourself wearing a planner's hat and focusing on land use and transportation, and how much are you looking forward to focusing on non-planning issues?
Some of the most pressing concerns facing Los Angeles are ultimately related to planning and land use. In fact, some of the issues I centered in my campaign, affordable housing and homelessness, were among the most important issues residents identified as challenges within the city and in the district, and they were top of mind during the campaign. In many ways they're rooted in planning. There's also a whole area of work around renter protections and homelessness that we're working on, but even the issues that I think are not directly planning-related are ultimately planning-related.
I'd love to talk to you about homelessness and poverty, since that's been a lot of your career focus. I think that's something planners have struggled with, partly because planning is generally considered a long-term prospect, and homelessness is an immediate crisis. What do you think planners in LA and throughout the state can be doing, or should be thinking, specifically in terms of homelessness?
One of the things my planning degree brings me is an awareness of, and a sympathy for, bureaucracies and how things move through them, and an awareness of how changing those processes can have a transformative impact on outcomes for the city.
When I'm talking about something like homelessness, one of the biggest challenges is finding, building and making available housing for people experiencing homelessness. That means either building new housing or making existing units available. One of the things we're looking at right now is a shared housing model. Can you make spaces available in multi-bedroom houses, for example, for families to live in a group setting, or in multi-bedroom apartments where couples or individuals could live? So, different households in one living unit. Or dormitory-style housing, if you're doing motel conversions, which are on the table now because of something like Project Homekey from the state, or if you're doing dormitory-style construction in the city. All of these involve planning changes for them to work.
With shared housing, a big barrier is actually our fire codes, which prevent multiple households from living in one unit. We have to look at how we can work with the fire department and other departments within the city to make this kind of housing available and safe. What about the fire code needs to change for this shared housing model to work and be safe for residents? I think that's incredibly important.
The other piece is when we're actually constructing housing. My awareness of the processes and bureaucracies involved in planning and construction has made me attuned to the challenges builders have when they go through the process of building affordable housing: how long those processes are, how much time each step takes, and how we can overcome those hurdles and shorten the process to make a lot more housing available. That awareness really does come from having gone to planning school, having dealt with city planning departments and city bureaucracies in general, and having a number of contacts in my circle who are working on these issues at every level of intervention. I see the challenges they're facing and learn from them as well.
Have you had a chance to have this sort of discussion with members of LA City Planning, be it Director Bertoni or other members of his staff?
We have started those conversations, but we are not even fully staffed up in our planning department yet, so those conversations haven't moved forward as much as others that have felt a little more timely.
Let me zoom out to the state level, specifically with RHNA. The city of LA has been allocated over 400,000 units for the cycle. The city reportedly embraced that number, whereas there were some disputes among other cities. How do you feel about that number, and what does it mean for your district? Have you had to sell that number or discuss it with your constituents yet, and what it might mean for them?
I think people are aware of the allocation. We have in this district a number of groups that have been involved in planning and land use discussions statewide: homeowners associations and other folks who have been deeply engaged on these issues for many years. So, of course, we've been having conversations with them, as part of our broader outreach to community groups, about what the RHNA allocations might mean for particular neighborhoods, and how we can accommodate those allocations while keeping alive and thriving the aspects of the neighborhood that are exciting for residents. We've been very willing to have that conversation, and once we've filled out our planning team, I think we'll be able to take on a lot more of that kind of deep community engagement.
The question I always ask when I go to these community groups that have been engaged on these issues for a long time is how we can solve these problems and challenges together, and I'm excited to be in a process of conversation and engagement with them.
The other piece is that in Los Angeles there are lots of people who have no idea what RHNA means, and who don't know what the housing element is, even though these terms and processes will have a pretty big impact on what the city looks like in a decade. Part of the work of our office is educating people about the importance of these issues, why it matters that their voices and perspectives are heard, and how they can get involved in a productive way. We're not quite fully staffed yet, but as we fill out our staff in the next couple of weeks, we're really excited to take on these conversations head on and widen the circle of people involved in these discussions.
There have often been tactics such as warning people about the "Manhattanization" of Los Angeles. Some of that messaging comes from the AIDS Healthcare Foundation, which is almost in your district. Would Manhattanization be a good thing or a bad thing? Is that a stereotype, or is there a grain of truth to it? How do you respond to those discussions that were happening before your time?
One of the things I always talked about was trying to make sure that the kind of new building happening in the city of Los Angeles actually addresses our biggest needs. Setting aside the question of Manhattanization or not, what we were looking at before I stepped into this role, and even now, is that the construction happening in Los Angeles is producing a lot of relatively expensive units and not enough affordable units. It's not meeting the gaps. There aren't enough units available for people who are housing insecure, or who are about to fall into or exit homelessness.
So one of the overarching questions we've been asking is to look at our planning code and at what's being built, and ask what blocks people face as they try to build exactly this kind of housing. One thing we're excited to start doing is being proactive. So far we've mostly been in reactive mode, because we're just starting to put our processes in place. Proactively, we want to think about how to build housing that fills those gaps. What I'm excited about in Los Angeles is that there's relatively wide agreement that those gaps exist. So if we can find policy that will generate that kind of housing, I think we can also build a wider base of support around it.
And how do you feel about funding for subsidized housing for the very low income, which I know is a great concern of yours?
One of the biggest issues I talked about on the campaign trail was Los Angeles's biggest recent intervention, Prop HHH, which in some ways didn't meet the expectations the city had for it. In part, I think, that was because of the failures of the bureaucracy to make rules around it that would generate the number of units, at the cost, that we needed.
A big part of what we're doing going forward is building public support for more subsidized housing, wherever that money is coming from. We have a big opportunity right now because of COVID, which has brought into relief how much support the city of Los Angeles needs. Through interventions targeted at COVID, like Project Roomkey and Project Homekey, there has actually been more state investment in exactly this kind of housing. I'm really excited to find opportunities to rent rooms in the district and to purchase motels, hotels and smaller apartment buildings to add to our subsidized housing stock in the city.
You mentioned state programs like Project Homekey. Let me ask a different state question. We have a few housing bills coming up: SB 9, the duplex bill, and SB 10, which is sort of a rehash of SB 50. Cities have strong feelings about bills like that. What are your feelings as a council member?
I didn't have one opinion on all of the state housing bills during my campaign, and I have to confess that, given how much work we've taken on, I haven't had the opportunity since I got into office to examine the new versions of the state bills coming down the pipeline. During the campaign, I did speak out against some of the state housing bills and in favor of others. I didn't like SB 50 for a number of reasons, including the very real concerns I heard about the displacement and gentrification that would result if those rules were adopted. I did like, in many ways, SB 1120. I had some concerns about high fire zones and about not wanting more construction encouraged in very high fire zones, and we have a number of those in the district. But that kind of bill was more exciting to me, and I felt it would address some of the needs we were facing in Los [Angeles — transcript cut off]. I'm excited, as we move forward, to look at the new housing bills coming down and evaluate them further.
I will say one thing, though. As someone who has been an observer of the city for far longer than I've had any real power in it, one of the things I felt in the broader debates over Sacramento versus Los Angeles controlling what happens locally is that our local representatives have in many ways not made the kind of tough decisions around zoning and planning that would have enabled us to build the housing, especially affordable housing, that we so desperately need here. If we can do more of that locally, and use this housing element process to really think about it and take action, I think some of the debates around legislation coming from Sacramento will be moot, because we'll have taken on those problems head on locally.
My last question is more of a personal one. As a planner, what has informed your perspective on planning? Are there books, theories, scholars, or personal experiences that you're bringing to the job and find yourself thinking about on a regular basis?
Oh, that's a really good question. I was just reading an excellent book about Los Angeles called The Reluctant Metropolis...
...which was written by our publisher, Bill Fulton.
Oh, really? Well, he'll be very glad to know I'm in the middle of reading that book. It has been a fascinating insight into not just why LA looks the way it does today, but into the partnerships that produced some of the land use decisions that continue to shape Los Angeles: environmentalists and people who cared about neighborhoods working together. And also the incredible power individual real estate developers had over the shape of the city. It has been fascinating to understand the past, and I hope it will help me better inform my actions in the present.
And what about further back in your career, especially your work on poverty? What's a seminal moment in that career?
One of the biggest issues I worked on in India was informality. So many of the settlements where low-income residents lived were not on official maps. They weren't given services, and they weren't given land rights. In part, that was because these were built outside of the state planning processes, so the cities just ignored their existence entirely. Access to services became an ad hoc effort for many residents of these communities, handled through politics. In understanding what was happening there, James Scott's Seeing Like a State really helped me shape my thinking about the work I did.
Councilmember Nithya Raman of Los Angeles, thanks very much for joining us, and we wish you all the best in your new political career.
Thank you so much, Josh. I appreciate you taking the time.

