The Promise of Nithya Raman, Los Angeles' New Planner-Mayor
This article is brought to you courtesy of the paying subscribers to California Planning & Development Report. You can subscribe to CP&DR by clicking here. You can sign up for CP&DR’s free weekly newsletter here.
I claim no powers of prophecy.
When I interviewed Nithya Raman in 2021 -- the only time I’ve ever done a standalone Q&A with a Los Angeles City Council member -- I did so not because I knew she would become mayor one day but rather because she was an urban planner. Raman came to the council with a master’s degree in planning from MIT, making her one of the few, if only, big-city elected officials trained in what is arguably the most fundamental function of city government.
Today, she might be the highest-ranking urban planner in the entire country.
Think about it: Los Angeles--the city that everyone loves to ridicule (accurately or not) for “having no urban planning” has an urban planner for a mayor.
The 55 percent of Los Angeles voters who favored Raman did so for a multitude of complex, sometimes vague, and perhaps even conflicting reasons. The biggest reason: she’s not Karen Bass. The second-biggest reason: she’s not Spencer Pratt.
But, who, exactly, is she in the context of Los Angeles?
Her most notable characteristic and, perhaps, greatest advantage isn’t that she went to MIT but, rather, that she is a newcomer.
Born in India, Raman grew up in Massachusetts, went to school in Boston (twice), went back to India for a spell, and didn’t move to Los Angeles until 2013. She founded SELAH Neighborhood Homeless Coalition, which she ran before running for City Council in 2021.
Let’s compare her rise with that of her predecessors.
By my rough calculation, the six mayors of post-Prop. 13 Los Angeles lived here for a collective 300 years. Maybe more. That lineage begins with Tom Bradley, who became the city’s first non-white mayor in 1973, and ends with the doldrums of Bass. Among them are literally two scions of prominent local politicians (Eric Garcetti, James Hahn), a career politician (Antonio Villaraigosa), and a consummate pillar of the community (Richard Riordan). Each of them represented a different wing of The Establishment.
In the most recent installment, Bass alienated voters for a host of reasons. Homelessness got worse; small businesses failed; and the city generally seemed to decline under her watch. Most notably, much of the outrage over the Palisades Fire fell on her. More generally, she exuded a vibe of passivity and was low-key to a fault--not a great look for a great world city. To her credit, her biggest accomplishment on housing, Executive Directive 1, facilitated the permitting of over 40,000 affordable housing units. How many will be built is another matter.
I do not want to lionize the “outsider” per se. Some real kooks come from the “outside.” And yet, these six mayors--not to mention the ones that preceded them--are both the products and perpetuators of a regrettable political culture. Allowing for a few progressive (lowercase p) successes--like the expansion of public transit, recovery from the 1994 earthquake, and development of Downtown L.A.-- none ever recognized the truth about modern Los Angeles: that, now that it’s built out and now that it’s one of the wealthiest places on the planet, it can, should, and must embrace urbanism.

I’m a sucker for stories of actors, musicians, and other dreamers who step off the bus and into the recording studio, sound stage, or writers room. Invariably, the people who like LA the best are transplants. They are dazzled by the city’s life, landscape, diversity, and opportunity. They forgive or don’t even notice the problems--and are, usually, utterly divorced from civic affairs. Meanwhile, the locals peer distrustfully through their hedges, guard their tee times, and mutter about traffic.
Raman is the first mayor whose background reflects the Los Angeles dream. She can recognize the need to get excited on behalf of the greater good. Because the status quo is the greater bad.
***
The unofficial start of the YIMBY movement was 2016. Some of Raman’s most enthusiastic supporters are developers and now formidable YIMBY organizations, like Abundant Housing Los Angeles and the Liveable Cities Initiative. That makes her the first truly YIMBY mayor in Los Angeles’ history. (By contrast, Villaraigosa and Garcetti were reasonably exuberant, but they focused on transit more than housing.) The question is, how will she promote the many thousands of units that she envisions? How will she improve the city’s fabric?
Raman reflects many of the tensions within the field of planning itself.
In planning, progressive ideas almost always must confront sluggish realities, dragged down by the weight of regulations, traditions, competing interests, timidity, and apathy. When new ideas are applied to built-out places, like Los Angeles, the existing built environment seems overwhelming. The response is to prevent changes, or to permit new development with so many qualifications and restrictions that it becomes impossible or, at best, comedic. It’s as if the complexity of the regulations has to rival the complexity of the city itself.
As a friend recently tweeted, “Urban planning should be thought of less like designing a garden and more like tending a forest.” Instead, we get a vacant, overgrown lot filled with crap.
Ideally, planning would do some weeding so often. Except, we can’t do it physically. We can’t bulldoze away the mediocrity. And, we can’t erase every regulation. We can’t un-spend or un-earmark funds. We can’t fire everyone who should be fired.
That brings us to ethos.
Raman is positioned not to perpetuate the city’s stagnation but, rather, to be appalled by it--and to tell us as much. On the campaign trail, she shared choice words about city departments, procedures, and, indeed, her own city council colleagues. She was fed up -- not in the whiny way that Pratt is but in the way of an intelligent person who can see how awful some of the problems are and how easy some of the solutions might be. She doesn’t have to defend tradition. And, she does not have to govern by fear -- fear of stepping out of line; fear of upsetting her supporters; fear of getting yelled at by a tiny minority of whiny constituents who are bent on ruining the city for everyone else.
It’s true that the mayor is just one person. And yet, a mayor’s vocal promotion of housing and development can accomplish a great deal--without requiring the passage of a single ordinance. It can amplify the electorate, reminding everyone on a regular basis--not just every four years--of what 50-plus percent of the voters want. It can set the tone for city staff, and, especially, department heads, to tell them how they will be judged. It puts city council members on notice, making anti-development factions the bad guys. It tells energetic, well intentioned staffers that it’s OK to be ambitious.
At the same time, the DSA association puts her in league with some serious anti-planning, anti-development forces, insofar as the DSA’s concerns for social justice mean that they oppose gentrification. On this count, Raman has supported strong renter protections, making some landlords and developers nervous. Supporting new development and renter protections will require creativity and political savvy.
To achieve these goals, Raman will need skills that she probably didn’t learn in planning school. She’s done enough well so far--in politics, 55% is as good as an A+. She just has to remember that the campaign never ends.
***
I’d like to think that Los Angeles’s worst days are behind it. Cautiously, I’d say the same for many other cities.
As we wrote a few weeks ago, the Trump regime and MAGA culture have not been kind to California. We counted over 30 explicit directives or legal actions that have attacked various aspects of California urbanism. And, Trump routinely harangues California -- usually inaccurately -- for harboring all the country’s problems.
Many policies not aimed directly at cities have, nonetheless, hindered them, disadvantaged them, and undermined their ability to do what they do best: generate commerce and bring people together. These policies include immigration raids, rollbacks on clean energy, electoral gerrymandering (oops!), cuts to transit funding, restriction on professional and student visas, loosening of environmental laws, gutting of education and research, suppression of trade, and much more.
(It’s worth noting that mayors and cities have long faced problems that ought not be their responsibility to fix. Homelessness, for instance, is a problem with local symptoms, but should be addressed at the national level.)
For ten long years, American cities and, especially, California cities have had to operate under the fear, frustration, revulsion, and, at best, carnival-style amusement that is MAGA.
That’s why Mayor Raman faces maybe the greatest opportunity in at least a generation. She--plus her recently elected Millennial and Millenial-adjacent counterparts like Daniel Lurie (San Francisco), Matt Mahan (San Jose), Katie Wilson (Seattle), Michelle Wu (Boston), and, of course, Zohran Mandami (New York City)--can govern exuberantly, robustly, without fear and with at least a shred of hope that their progressive counterparts in DC will support them. (It’s a quirk of the electoral calendar that Raman was the only new mayor of a major city to be elected with the Blue Tsunami.)
Raman and her California counterparts can also ride the tailwinds of state legislation. As far as I can tell, Raman harbors none of the resentment toward Sacramento that many other local electeds do. She might actually want to accommodate and benefit from laws like SB 79 rather than spend all her effort figuring out how to minimize their effects.
If things go even moderately well for these mayors, they will create a virtuous cycle. Their cities will get better. Housing will get built. People will move into the housing, enjoy the cities, and stay put. More people will arrive and fewer will leave. They will support the politicians and party(s) accordingly. Meanwhile, anti-urban factions will have fewer failures to henpeck.
Back in 2021, Raman was obscure enough that she thanked me for pronouncing her name correctly. Now, everyone in Los Angeles knows her name.


